Posted on 01 October 2006, at 4:27 pm, by Judie Lipsett
I’ve been using the HTC Universal (branded as an i-mate JasJar) for almost a year. This in itself has been a bit out of the norm, because many of the PDAs I’ve owned haven’t lasted near as long.
Let’s go tripping down memory lane, shall we?
The first pen-based (or stylus entry) Personal Digital Assistant that I remember buying was the Casio Zoomer, sometime in 1993. Beyond the contacts, calendar and Pocket Quicken that came loaded on the device, there was also a version of Pyramid that I could literally waste hours playing. The resulting scratches and scribbles on the screen would eventually help shape my firm belief in the value of screen protectors.
I bought my first Pilot from the Franklin catalog; Franklin as in the day planner company! This was in late 1996, and I can’t even remember what the cost of a brand new Pilot was, but a little known fact was that if you looked in the paper insert in the middle of their catalog - Franklin also sold refurbs. I wasn’t sure if I would like the blocky little monochrome device, so I reasoned that buying a slightly used one would be prudent. Up until then I had been using various keyboard-input clamshell devices, including my longtime favorite the HP-95LX and several of its upgraded future generations.
Once I got that first Pilot, I was hooked. I mastered Graffiti very quickly, and used to amuse family and friends with the way that I would obsessively jot everything down in the device.
Remember the days before rechargeable batteries? I can remember always keeping a supply in my desk drawer and in my bag. It was completely wasteful, really; when my battery bar hit a certain level I would change the batteries. I was so afraid of losing my data that I got quite proficient at changing the batteries quickly. Even so, I still managed to lose my data a few times because I took an extra second or two too long to complete the process…thank goodness for Palm Desktop and hot-sync’d data!
Ah, those were the good old days.
I was completely loyal to the Palm / Pilot branded line from 1996 to 2000; I bought every new version that came out whether I needed it or not…and then came the IIIc in 2000; this was true gadget nirvana. I had to have every available accessory because this was the PDA I thought I would use for years! I was so naive. My favorite feature was its 160 x 160 color screen. Some reviewers opined that the IIIc was too blocky, said it was slightly sluggish or complained there weren’t enough applications taking advantage of the color; I turned a deaf ear.
However, I would soon be swayed to the Pocket PC side of things…
My next true love was the Compaq iPAQ 3600. It’s beautiful QVGA TFT 240 x 320 color screen and sleek silver curves gave me a solid case of gadget lust. Once again I went crazy with accessories, even convincing a jeweler friend of mine that there was a market for luxury styli. Somewhere in my jewelry box I still have a sterling silver iPAQ 3600 stylus with an emerald cabochon circled by pave diamonds. Just using it to enter items in my calendar or tasks was completely decadent! I felt guilty moving on to the next PDA, because a new PDA meant a new stylus; I sadly had to retire that beauty.
Over the next few years I bought several different versions and upgrades of the quickly appearing iPAQ models; I felt that with few exceptions, they were they only Pocket PC game in town.
That’s not to say that I didn’t flirt with various other manufacturer’s offerings, such as those by Asus, Viewsonic, Casio, etc., etc. - I just always came back to the iPAQ.
Eventually Sony entered the hardware arena, introducing their exciting and innovative Palm OS line. The CLÍE was a device that I couldn’t resist, so I started buying its various incarnations - I even bought the massive NZ90 with its 2 mega pixel camera (until then unheard of in a PDA), improved keyboard, and 320 x 480 resolution screen. So what if it was a brick? It was a pleasure to use.
However, it wasn’t much longer before Sony stepped out of the Palm device arena, and their absence left a gaping hole. With no hardware company’s pushing them, Palm was free to regurgitate an array of largely unexciting devices running on their aging operating system. The last time I bought a Palm device was when the Tapwave Zodiac appeared. In my opinion, this was their last truly innovative PDA…and the company disappeared within only a couple of years.
I went back to the iPAQ - the hx4700 this time (True VGA, 4″ screen), then gave the Sprint Pocket PC Phone PPC-6700 a try (QVGA, 2.8″ screen), and then finally settled comfortably with the Universal (True VGA, 3.7″ screen) after being quite pleased with a loaner Microsoft sent for review last year.
And that’s the device I have been happy using since…until I was presented with an HTC Hermes (branded Dopod 838Pro) at Mobius last week. The Hermes is a Quad-band GSM Pocket PC Phone with a QVGA 2.8″ screen and a 2 mega pixel camera.
You would think that it would be a no-brainer for me to switch to the Hermes: The Universal is bigger, no EDGE, and in some ways already outdated, but it does everything I need and it does it very well. Could the Hermes really the better device for me? Could it be the perfect device for you?
Give me a couple of weeks and after I have used the Hermes exclusively as my main brain, I’ll write its review and answer those questions and many more.
October 1st, 2006 at 5:06 pm
I don’t understand; the Hermes has a smaller resolution, smaller sized screen, a slower processor, smaller keyboard. . .aside from it being Quad-band and having a nicer camera, it seems like the Universal’s the better bet. Does it an extra graphics processor or something? I’m cornfused.
Doug
October 1st, 2006 at 5:17 pm
Ha! Many of your objections are the exact ones I have been throwing back at friends who’re telling me that the Hermes is the “second coming” of the PDA!
To be fair, there are a couple of features that make it a very intriguing choice, like the scroll wheel on the upper left side, its more pocketable size, and the layout of its buttons - just to name a few.
The Hermes really is a slick little device…I just don’t know if I will be able to go back to such a small screen and lesser (IMHO) keyboard.
Time will tell; I am loading it with applications right now.
October 1st, 2006 at 6:03 pm
Well, I’m probably picky because my two favorite applications/uses for my PDA are eReader and watching videos, so having a big screen is pretty important to me. That’s one thing that drives me crazy about these convergent devices; all the phone manufacturers (at least, the ones that target *this* country) seem to have taken some kind of vow to have a maximum screen resolution of 320×240, which I find a major step back.
But like I say, I’m picky.
October 1st, 2006 at 6:18 pm
I’m sold on the DoPod, for now. I’ve been using it to send and receive email and even administer a site or two. It’s a solid device and it’s SO EASY to just extend the keyboard when you want to type a lot of stuff.
I was a hard core Pocket PC user until the Smartphone came into my life. Now that I’ve been using the DoPod I’m finding that my Smartphone is more of a “going out for the night” device, and not nearly the workhorse I once thought it was. Then again, I’ve also got the i320 on deck so the DoPod may be short lived in my gear bag, not to mention that the Excalibur really is sexy, and then there’s the Treo 750 and then . . .
October 1st, 2006 at 7:35 pm
Judie, great site, btw!
-Joel
October 1st, 2006 at 9:34 pm
Thanks Joel
@Doug: I’m a huge eBook reader, too. That’s what makes giving up the Universal’s large screen unappealing. But the Hermes’ scroll wheel does look handy! Too bad HTC won’t release a Universal with a scroll wheel.
October 1st, 2006 at 9:52 pm
Wow! Quite a shock to find out via jkOnTheRun that you now have your own site. I’ve been a fan for a few years and actually didn’t even know most of the gadgets out there had there not been theGadgeteer. Congrats on your new site. Looking forward to more great stuff!
And thanks for a quick intro on where you’ve been. It’s always nice to read.
October 1st, 2006 at 10:07 pm
Hi maceyr, it’s great to have you here.
October 1st, 2006 at 11:07 pm
Judie, grats on the new site!
I’ve used a loaner Hermes for the last few days, and I agree with you, it’s great. I’m going to hold off on buying one for a few months (having been burned badly as an early adopter several times, I like to wait to make sure the manufacturing defects are resolved), but it’s definitely my next device.
—Ellen
October 1st, 2006 at 11:10 pm
Hi Ellen! Wow, this feels like old home week!!
Your vote of confidence is a good one for the Hermes…I feel like we should start a score board.
October 2nd, 2006 at 12:36 am
I thought the Hermes also has UMTS/HSDPA connectivity. I’m not certain, because I honestly haven’t had the opportunity to put my hands on one. Don’t know that I will either. I’m on a huge convergence kick right now, and with being in a new city (we purchased a home in Oswego, IL this past weekend… we’re new to that part of Chicago) I’m going to get a lot of use out of the iPAQ 6515 I have. I’m really looking at picking up the 6945, and wouldn’t seriously consider any device that didn’t have QUAD GSM, EDGE, GPS and WM5. I’m not real big on WiFi, so I know I won’t use it a lot (don’t need it with the unlimited data package I’ve got), and don’t want to pay more for UTMS/HSDPA.
I’m also very big into non-sliding keyboard access. My K-JAM is getting a bit wiggly and I don’t want to damage it, so I’ve given it a break.
What’s the keyboard slider like, Judie? Is it similar to the Wizard?
October 2nd, 2006 at 1:06 am
Hi Chris, today is the first day that I have really started using the Hermes…so I hate to make any snap judgements about anything.
However, the keyboard slider does feels very solid. I have never owned a Wizard, but I did have the Apache and this slider feels as good or better.
I want to give HTC kudos for the matte black case and the overall look of the Hermes. I never warmed to the painted silver of the Apache; this feels much more professional and classy.
I haven’t yet dived into the Hermes specs, but a quick glance at the Dopod site shows the 838Pro/Hermes has EDGE/GPRS/UMTS, GSM Quadband (850/900/1800/1900)+WCDMA Triband (850/1900/2100). XDA Developer’s Hermes Wiki shows GSM 850/900/1800/1900, GPRS, EDGE, UMTS(3G), HSDPA(3.5G).
It’s funny you said that about not needing WiFi: I might have felt the same way since I have an unlimited data plan through T-mobile, but when I got to Franfurt and then Thailand, the only way I could get online with my JasJar was by either connecting via UMTS/GPRS (at $15 a MB!!) or via WiFi when it was available. I was really glad to have the WiFi option, especially in the Mobius meeting rooms where it was free.
I had to use UMTS/GPRS more than I would have liked on the trip; I am not looking forward to that bill…but it was worth it!
Now obviously I don’t leave the country every day, but having more ways to connect opens more options and allows you to roll with whatever situation is presented.
October 2nd, 2006 at 12:50 pm
Great site, Judie — glad to see a fellow “gadget geek” doing well!
I’ve had the HTC TyTN, same as your JasJam except for color, since it came out 6 week ago. It is truly a great device! I had the K-Jam before so this was not a major change for me, although I went from the IPAQ hx4700 to the K-Jam and that took a bit of getting used to. But I quickly discovered that I much prefer the smaller size in my hand and pocket and the display is not only quite readible but I’ve come to like it better than the larger ones because it is so convenient in my palm. I have the slingmedia player on my TyTN and it’s great — when used in landscape the picture is actually large enough and clear enough to read Fox News’ ticker on the bottom. Only problem with slingplayer is finding a fast enough cell connection — Cingular 3G isn’t in my area yet. I agree with your comment regarding wifi — originally thought I wouldn’t need it, but it’s really handy to have and often offers the better choice for bandwidth/speed.
October 2nd, 2006 at 1:40 pm
Hi Judie, just vistied your new site, it’s really great! Keep going! ^_^y
From this article knowing that your are a heavy user on using palm sized devices. Here’s my old site that share with you. Hope it will remind you something…
http://www.palmislife.com/~larrydiy/
This old site contents really “HARD” things and sorry it’s all in Chinese characters again… -__- However, pictures tell everything.
I’ve been using my Hermes for 5 days. It does have a nicer appearance than HTC cht9000 (a custom-made model launched by Chung-Hua Telecom Taiwan) though they somewhat look like twins. Not to mention WiFi function build-in, in my country, 3G(384kbps) is definite a cheaper option and runs faster than GPRS for conneting onto internet. Especially 3.5G will soon be kicked-off (start from 1.8Mbps then up to 3.6Mbps)and Hermes has been ready for it with its HSDPA spec.
Unfortunately I am getting mad on tuning my Hermes. Some problems still need to be resolved. I will share with you once I got answers…