Comments on: iPhone Application “Kill Switch” Confirmed

By: Christopher Gavula

Christopher Gavula — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 18:34:35 +0000

I think voting with your dollars is always good advice. There are things to like and things to put up with on every platform and I think you just have to pick the mix that works best for you.

By: n0doz

n0doz — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 18:24:03 +0000

I prefer to call it personal preference. Programs that don’t work with a given device is (are?) one thing; a device that “kills” the app (and I’m not too fond of how that info came out, BTW) is something else entirely, I think.
After all, once you buy the item, you expect that you can use it how you wish (and no comparisons to Windows, please – there are so many Windows apps these days, it seems impossible not to find exactly what you want that will work with the big W… and none I’ve found get “killed,” either.) I guess if a person likes Apple, they’ll put up with this sort of thing. I’m not a user, and I see no reason to switch, especially if this is how Apple does things.
Not a “love” or “hate” issue for me… just easier to stay where I’m at (Moto Q) for now.

By: Christopher Gavula

Christopher Gavula — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 16:39:16 +0000

I don’t think “pessimistic” is the right word, no. Sarcastic, perhaps? Given the comments I’ve seen lately on similar stories, I think my expectations are pretty realistic.

I like the iPhone and own one (as well as a Windows Mobile based phone) and I don’t consider this a reason “not” to buy one. Clearly, however, you do. Isn’t that a bit pessimistic?

By: n0doz

n0doz — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 15:53:15 +0000

“So now we’ll get to hear from the Apple fanboys about how Apple is protecting us, from the Apple bashers how Apple is just “Big Brother” and from the MS fanboys who are bitter that MS didn’t do it first.”

Gee, Chris, that’s a little pessimistic, don’t you think?
I prefer to just call it a good reason not to buy one.

By: Wayne Schulz

Wayne Schulz — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 15:52:33 +0000

I’m actually more curious about why there is no SlingPlayer for iphone.

Is it because Apple is trying to position a revised Apple TV in that space??

Also think about how this list could possibly be used in other ways — expiring licenses, banning competing applications …

Agree that until someone is affected, this will bubble below the surface…

By: Christopher Gavula

Christopher Gavula — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 15:17:07 +0000

I suspect this won’t actually come to a head until something actually has to be shut down. Until then, there will likely be some level of concern, but no real outrage.

Even if their review process was fixed, that’s no guarantee that a “rogue” app couldn’t slip through.

My personal take is that, although this concerns me, I’m not certain that this make me mad. Apple has a controlled store in which they “approve” apps (although how much inspection happens is still up for debate). If an app went “bad” Apple would likely be blamed for not checking it before approving it. Therefore, I can’t say I blame Apple for putting in a safety mechanism to cover themselves. What I CAN be annoyed with is that they weren’t up front with the info.

By: Christopher Spera

Christopher Spera — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 15:14:31 +0000

Personally, I don’t think they would need a kill switch if their review process got fixed… but that’s just me.

By: iPhone News » Blog Archive » iPhone Application “Kill Switch” Confirmed

Mon, 11 Aug 2008 15:10:41 +0000

[...] Christopher Gavula created an interesting post today on iPhone Application â��Kill Switchâ�� ConfirmedHere’s a short outlineThis morning, Engadget and electronista.com are reporting (apparently … [visit site to read more] [...]

By: Wayne Schulz

Wayne Schulz — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 15:05:19 +0000

Definitely interested to see how this blacklist plays out.

Right now I think the biggest issue with App Store is that slow speed with which new programs and updates are added. Once they fix that I’m sure this blacklist will come to the forefront (eventually).