Comments on: Are you buying a Palm Pre? Yes or No — and tell us why http://www.geardiary.com/2009/05/20/are-you-buying-a-palm-pre-yes-or-no-and-tell-us-why/ Everyone can understand technology; sometimes it just takes a little translating. Wed, 15 Feb 2012 02:34:00 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: reidmehttp://www.geardiary.com/2009/05/20/are-you-buying-a-palm-pre-yes-or-no-and-tell-us-why/#comment-45059 reidme Thu, 21 May 2009 01:48:07 +0000 http://www.geardiary.com/?p=30226#comment-45059 I'm getting it day one (or hopefully sooner as a Sprint Premier customer.) I think one reason Palm is beginning the launching on Sprint alone is supply; they are already predicting shortages. Why have it more widely available if they can't meet demand? They are spacing out the launches on other carriers and other regions to spread out the demand as they ramp up supply. I’m getting it day one (or hopefully sooner as a Sprint Premier customer.) I think one reason Palm is beginning the launching on Sprint alone is supply; they are already predicting shortages. Why have it more widely available if they can’t meet demand? They are spacing out the launches on other carriers and other regions to spread out the demand as they ramp up supply.

]]> By: Joel McLaughlinhttp://www.geardiary.com/2009/05/20/are-you-buying-a-palm-pre-yes-or-no-and-tell-us-why/#comment-45038 Joel McLaughlin Wed, 20 May 2009 20:40:19 +0000 http://www.geardiary.com/?p=30226#comment-45038 As I just switched to a GSM carrier, no way. Even though T-Mobile did not work in the sticks and Sprint did, I would not switch. The Palm Pre is starting to become like the ever elusive US version of Cupcake (here's a hint T-Mobile....I appreciate it that you are trying to make it bug free, but to promise it for an entire month, well....there ya go. Also, there's no such thing as bug free software. Just release it dang it! As I just switched to a GSM carrier, no way. Even though T-Mobile did not work in the sticks and Sprint did, I would not switch. The Palm Pre is starting to become like the ever elusive US version of Cupcake (here’s a hint T-Mobile….I appreciate it that you are trying to make it bug free, but to promise it for an entire month, well….there ya go. Also, there’s no such thing as bug free software. Just release it dang it!

]]> By: doogaldhttp://www.geardiary.com/2009/05/20/are-you-buying-a-palm-pre-yes-or-no-and-tell-us-why/#comment-45029 doogald Wed, 20 May 2009 14:36:54 +0000 http://www.geardiary.com/?p=30226#comment-45029 Probably not buying it. First, I'm in a Verizon contract until December. Second, I'm strongly considering moving to AT&T for an iPhone then because my VZW signal stinks at home, has not improved, it seems it will not anytime soon, and I learned that AT&T - which used to have no signal at my house - suddenly has a fairly strong 3G signal here. Sprint will be no better than VZW, so, simply for the ability to actually use the thing, I really doubt that I would go to a Pre. And $299 with a rebate you need to wait for? Who the heck likes that kind of a deal, when the major smartphone players are all available at $199 out of pocket or less? Dumb, dumb, dumb. Probably not buying it. First, I’m in a Verizon contract until December. Second, I’m strongly considering moving to AT&T for an iPhone then because my VZW signal stinks at home, has not improved, it seems it will not anytime soon, and I learned that AT&T – which used to have no signal at my house – suddenly has a fairly strong 3G signal here.

Sprint will be no better than VZW, so, simply for the ability to actually use the thing, I really doubt that I would go to a Pre.

And $299 with a rebate you need to wait for? Who the heck likes that kind of a deal, when the major smartphone players are all available at $199 out of pocket or less? Dumb, dumb, dumb.

]]> By: kiffmeisterhttp://www.geardiary.com/2009/05/20/are-you-buying-a-palm-pre-yes-or-no-and-tell-us-why/#comment-45026 kiffmeister Wed, 20 May 2009 13:58:44 +0000 http://www.geardiary.com/?p=30226#comment-45026 The lack of a GSM version is a dealbreaker for me too. I travel overseas a lot, and I want one smartphone for everywhere I go. The lack of a GSM version is a dealbreaker for me too. I travel overseas a lot, and I want one smartphone for everywhere I go.

]]> By: Gatewoodhttp://www.geardiary.com/2009/05/20/are-you-buying-a-palm-pre-yes-or-no-and-tell-us-why/#comment-45025 Gatewood Wed, 20 May 2009 13:46:51 +0000 http://www.geardiary.com/?p=30226#comment-45025 No way! Sprint is just not good where I live and AT&T is. I'm into Blackberry right now, and it's awfully hard to leave that. No way! Sprint is just not good where I live and AT&T is. I’m into Blackberry right now, and it’s awfully hard to leave that.

]]> By: Federico Cervellihttp://www.geardiary.com/2009/05/20/are-you-buying-a-palm-pre-yes-or-no-and-tell-us-why/#comment-45024 Federico Cervelli Wed, 20 May 2009 13:02:40 +0000 http://www.geardiary.com/?p=30226#comment-45024 Waiting for the GSM version too... My deal breaker could be a goofy native PIM suite (e.g. no categories), and a difficult migration path from older Palm OS devices. Waiting for the GSM version too…

My deal breaker could be a goofy native PIM suite (e.g. no categories), and a difficult migration path from older Palm OS devices.

]]> By: Judie Lipsetthttp://www.geardiary.com/2009/05/20/are-you-buying-a-palm-pre-yes-or-no-and-tell-us-why/#comment-45023 Judie Lipsett Wed, 20 May 2009 12:36:23 +0000 http://www.geardiary.com/?p=30226#comment-45023 I really feel that Palm dropped the ball by limiting themselves to a CDMA carrier. Sure, Sprint has a long-running relationship with them and I understand that, but I think they shot themselves in the foot by not going with a GSM carrier *worldwide* right off the bat. It seems to me that for a struggling company, limiting the number of people who can use your product right off the bat is foolish. OK - argue that Apple did that with the iPhone by making it US AT&T only, but did they really? How long did it take for people to get around that? Unfortunately their is no easy fix to get around CDMA. :-P Anyway. I liked what I saw at the Pre launch, and I hope it does well for them, but at this moment I am not feeling it. Maybe once I try it, who knows. :-P I really feel that Palm dropped the ball by limiting themselves to a CDMA carrier.

Sure, Sprint has a long-running relationship with them and I understand that, but I think they shot themselves in the foot by not going with a GSM carrier *worldwide* right off the bat.

It seems to me that for a struggling company, limiting the number of people who can use your product right off the bat is foolish.

OK – argue that Apple did that with the iPhone by making it US AT&T only, but did they really? How long did it take for people to get around that? Unfortunately their is no easy fix to get around CDMA. :-P

Anyway. I liked what I saw at the Pre launch, and I hope it does well for them, but at this moment I am not feeling it. Maybe once I try it, who knows. :-P

]]> By: mchinskyhttp://www.geardiary.com/2009/05/20/are-you-buying-a-palm-pre-yes-or-no-and-tell-us-why/#comment-45022 mchinsky Wed, 20 May 2009 12:31:17 +0000 http://www.geardiary.com/?p=30226#comment-45022 Not sure on the touch (I just don't think anybody can compete with Apple due to itunes in regards to music) There is rumors of an 'EOS' which is supposed to be a different form factor (smaller). Since the Pre has a real and virtual keyboard option, It maybe their modern incarnation of the Centro. Something the non-text happy mavin would want. I'm guessing once the OS is baked, the R&D for different form factors is relatively low. I'm buying one because, for a variety of reasons, I'm sticking with Sprint. I also like the fact that overall Sprint is always alot less expensive than AT&T and Verizon and has much better 3g coverage than AT&T. I'm hoping for a caching newsreader app at some point like Byline: http://www.phantomfish.com/byline.html It downloads your RSS feeds from Google Reader, and more importantly spider's down to the originally linked HTML and caches it. For the ipod touch that is key as wifi in the wild is pretty rare. As usual with Ipod/touch OS, it can't do the caching unless it is the forefront application. If they could do this on the pre, but fetch the updates and cached pages in the background, then when you read the newsfeeds and web pages, they should fly like broadband since they are coming out of memory. I don't see an iphone user hooked into AT&T switching but I bet you see alot of Blackberry users with iPhone envy switch as they aren't willing to give up the real keyboard (I have a Palm 700p and an iPod touch and there is no competition as to which one I want when I have to type more than a yes/no response to something. The big question is, how long until Verizon gets the Pre. That's when the sales trajectory will really take off. Not sure on the touch (I just don’t think anybody can compete with Apple due to itunes in regards to music)

There is rumors of an ‘EOS’ which is supposed to be a different form factor (smaller). Since the Pre has a real and virtual keyboard option, It maybe their modern incarnation of the Centro. Something the non-text happy mavin would want.

I’m guessing once the OS is baked, the R&D for different form factors is relatively low.

I’m buying one because, for a variety of reasons, I’m sticking with Sprint. I also like the fact that overall Sprint is always alot less expensive than AT&T and Verizon and has much better 3g coverage than AT&T.

I’m hoping for a caching newsreader app at some point like Byline:
http://www.phantomfish.com/byline.html

It downloads your RSS feeds from Google Reader, and more importantly spider’s down to the originally linked HTML and caches it.

For the ipod touch that is key as wifi in the wild is pretty rare. As usual with Ipod/touch OS, it can’t do the caching unless it is the forefront application.

If they could do this on the pre, but fetch the updates and cached pages in the background, then when you read the newsfeeds and web pages, they should fly like broadband since they are coming out of memory.

I don’t see an iphone user hooked into AT&T switching but I bet you see alot of Blackberry users with iPhone envy switch as they aren’t willing to give up the real keyboard (I have a Palm 700p and an iPod touch and there is no competition as to which one I want when I have to type more than a yes/no response to something.

The big question is, how long until Verizon gets the Pre. That’s when the sales trajectory will really take off.

]]> By: Wayne Schulzhttp://www.geardiary.com/2009/05/20/are-you-buying-a-palm-pre-yes-or-no-and-tell-us-why/#comment-45016 Wayne Schulz Wed, 20 May 2009 11:11:07 +0000 http://www.geardiary.com/?p=30226#comment-45016 I'm not feeling the "buzz" like I was a few months ago. Maybe that will change as June 6 approaches. Using an iPhone the only thing I'd like better is a tighter integration to Gmail. The problem with switching is that if I do so then I lose all those iPhone Apps that I love. Will be interesting to watch reaction to this. Sprint and Palm definitely seem to be in a do or die state. Also I'm wondering if we're going to see a Palm Pre type device without a cell phone (similar to iPod Touch). I’m not feeling the “buzz” like I was a few months ago. Maybe that will change as June 6 approaches. Using an iPhone the only thing I’d like better is a tighter integration to Gmail. The problem with switching is that if I do so then I lose all those iPhone Apps that I love.

Will be interesting to watch reaction to this. Sprint and Palm definitely seem to be in a do or die state. Also I’m wondering if we’re going to see a Palm Pre type device without a cell phone (similar to iPod Touch).

]]>